But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Prices & Guide (2026)
Quick Answer: But First Coffee Shop keeps drinks between $2.34–$8.98 and food between $4.50–$16, with lattes, avocado toast, and acai bowls as the standouts.
You’re scrolling through options for your next coffee run and just found But First Coffee Shop menu US listings but you have no idea what to order or how much to budget. That’s a normal spot to be in, especially with a menu this packed with specialty drinks. This faith-inspired coffee shop out of Orlando has built a loyal following in 2026 for its locally roasted coffee, hearty toasts, and Instagram-worthy acai bowls.
This guide walks through every category on the menu, from espresso and matcha to breakfast sandwiches and mini pancakes, with real prices pulled straight from their delivery listings.
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Hot Coffee & Espresso Prices
Hot coffee at But First starts as low as $2.34 for a straight espresso shot. Lattes and Americanos scale up by size, giving you flexibility depending on how much caffeine you want.
Drip coffee is the most budget-friendly hot option on the whole menu at $3.75–$4.95. Prices may vary slightly by outlet, since DoorDash pulls location-specific pricing for each store.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Espresso | Rich, flavorful shot brewed to perfection | $2.34 |
| Double Espresso | Bold double shot for a stronger kick | $3.38 |
| Drip 8oz | Balanced, smooth brewed coffee | $3.75 |
| Drip 12oz | Balanced flavor profile suited for any time of day | $4.11 |
| Drip 16oz | Fresh-brewed blend with a balanced flavor | $4.95 |
| Americano 8oz | Espresso combined with hot water | $4.50 |
| Americano 12oz | Espresso and hot water, medium size | $4.52 |
| Americano 16oz | Espresso gently combined with hot water | $5.25 |
| 8oz Latte | Steamed milk and a shot of espresso | $5.10 |
| 12oz Latte | Locally roasted espresso with steamed milk | $5.98 |
| 16oz Latte | Double shot espresso with steamed milk and foam | $6.55 |
| Macchiato | Espresso topped with a dollop of frothy milk | $5.72 |
| Cappuccino 8oz | Espresso and hot milk with generous foam | $5.50 |
| Decaf 8oz | Decaffeinated espresso with steamed milk | $4.68 |
| Decaf 12oz | Decaf latte, flavor options available | $5.98 |
| Decaf 16oz | Smooth decaf blend, largest size | $6.19 |
Tip: If you’re sensitive to caffeine but still want the full latte experience, the Decaf 12oz lets you pick a flavor like vanilla or caramel.
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Iced Lattes & Protein Lattes
Iced lattes run from $4.37 to $8.98, with flavored options landing on the higher end of that range. The Cookie Butter Lover and Flan Latte are the priciest specialty pours.
Protein iced lattes are a newer addition, priced around $8.53–$8.98 for a filling, workout-friendly option. Individual locations may have slightly different menu offerings depending on seasonal flavors.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Iced Americano | Chilled espresso served cold over ice | $4.37 |
| Iced Latte | Chilled espresso combined with milk | $5.98 |
| Vanilla Oat Milk Latte | Espresso and oat milk with a hint of vanilla | $7.50 |
| Cinnamon Dolce Oat Milk Latte | Espresso and oat milk with cinnamon dolce syrup | $7.18 |
| Caramel Iced Latte | Espresso and milk sweetened with caramel | $7.75 |
| Ice Mocha | Espresso and chocolate syrup with milk over ice | $7.25 |
| Brown Sugar Cinnamon Oat Latte | Espresso with brown sugar, cinnamon, and oat milk | $7.95 |
| Frances Latte | Signature espresso and milk, served over ice | $7.85 |
| Flan Latte | Espresso with caramelized sugar and creamy flan notes | $8.95 |
| Cookie Butter Lover Latte | Espresso with biscoff cookie butter and cold foam | $8.85 |
| Iced Decaf Latte | Double shot decaf espresso with milk over ice | $7.18 |
| Vanilla-Cinnamon Protein Iced Latte | Espresso, vanilla protein powder, milk, and cinnamon | $8.53 |
| Cookies & Cream Protein Iced Latte | Milk, cookies & cream protein powder, blended with ice | $8.98 |
Tip: The Frances Latte is named after the owner and comes up constantly in reviews — worth trying on your first visit.
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Mocha, Hot Chocolate & Matcha
Mocha drinks stay in a tight $5.15–$6.50 range regardless of size, making them an easy budget pick. Hot chocolate follows a similar pattern, topping out at $6.50 for the Spanish-style version.
Matcha lattes are the most premium non-coffee category, reaching up to $8.75 for the strawberry blend. Prices may vary slightly by outlet depending on syrup and topping availability.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Mocha 8oz | Espresso, chocolate, and steamed milk | $5.15 |
| Mocha 12oz | Espresso and chocolate with steamed milk | $5.95 |
| Mocha 16oz | Espresso and steamed milk with rich chocolate | $6.50 |
| Hot Chocolate 8oz | Steamed milk blended with rich chocolate | $5.15 |
| Hot Chocolate 12oz | Hot chocolate with steamed milk | $5.72 |
| Spanish Hot Chocolate 8oz | Thick, dense traditional hot chocolate | $5.98 |
| Spanish Hot Chocolate 12oz | Rich, thick chocolate in a larger portion | $6.50 |
| But First Matcha | Matcha blended with a base liquid | $7.99 |
| Honey Coconut Matcha | Matcha with coconut milk and a touch of honey | $7.95 |
| Ube Matcha Latte | Creamy matcha blended with subtly sweet ube | $8.25 |
| Strawberry Matcha | Ceremonial grade matcha blended with fresh strawberries | $8.75 |
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Teas & Juices
Tea drinkers get solid variety here, with prices ranging from $4.11 to $6.76 depending on size and style. Chai options come both hot and iced.
Fresh juices and lemonades are a refreshing alternative if you’re skipping caffeine altogether. Prices may vary slightly by outlet, especially for seasonal lemonade flavors like ube or parcha.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Earl Grey Tea 8oz | Black tea with citrus bergamot aroma | $4.11 |
| Earl Grey 12oz | Classic black tea infused with bergamot oil | $4.42 |
| English Breakfast 8oz | Robust, full-bodied black tea blend | $4.11 |
| English Breakfast 12oz | Rich, malty black tea blend | $4.42 |
| Chamomile Citrus Tea 12oz | Egyptian chamomile with soothing citrus notes | $4.42 |
| 8oz Chai Latte | Steamed milk blended with chai concentrate | $5.15 |
| 12oz Chai Latte | Spiced chai concentrate with steamed milk | $5.72 |
| Chai Latte 16oz | Black tea with cinnamon, cardamom, ginger, and milk | $6.24 |
| Iced Chai Oat Latte | Spiced chai tea and oat milk over ice | $6.50 |
| Vanilla Chai Iced Oat Latte | Iced chai with vanilla and oat milk | $6.76 |
| Lemonade | Refreshing classic citrus lemonade | $4.42 |
| Parcha Lemonade | Passion fruit and fresh lemon lemonade | $4.68 |
| Mango Lemonade | Sweet and tart mango-infused lemonade | $5.25 |
| Ube Lemonade | Purple yam blended with fresh lemon | $5.25 |
| Strawberry Lemonade | Strawberry-infused summer lemonade | $6.50 |
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Toasts & Pastries
Avocado toast is the star of this category, with prices climbing to $14.50 for the loaded smoked salmon version. Simpler toasts start closer to $8.50.
Pastries stay affordable, all priced under $5.00 each. They’re a smart add-on if you’re already ordering a drink. Individual locations may have slightly different menu offerings for daily pastry selection.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Peanut Butter & Banana Toast | Peanut butter, banana, honey, and chia seeds | $8.50 |
| Not Your Average Avo Toast | Mashed avocado, tomato, red onion, sesame, balsamic | $12.25 |
| Bacon & Egg Avocado Toast | Smashed avocado, bacon, fried egg on multi-grain | $14.00 |
| Breakfast Avocado Toast with Hot Honey Glaze | Sourdough, avocado, and hot honey glaze | $14.00 |
| Breakfast Avocado Toast w Feta Cheese | Sourdough, smashed avocado, feta, and lemon | $14.50 |
| Smoked Salmon Toast | Salmon, cream cheese, cucumber, capers, dill | $14.00 |
| Smoked Salmon Avocado Breakfast Toast | Sourdough, avocado, salmon, cream cheese, capers | $15.00 |
| Croissant | Buttery, flaky classic croissant | $4.85 |
| Quesito | Puff pastry filled with sweetened cream cheese | $4.50 |
| Guava & Cheese Pastry | Puff pastry with sweet guava and cheese | $4.90 |
Tip: The Breakfast Avocado Toast with Hot Honey Glaze is one of the most photographed items on their menu order it if you want the full experience.
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Fresh Kitchen & Breakfast
Savory breakfast items range from $6.50 to $12.50, covering everything from overnight oats to paninis. The Breakfast Sandwich Croissant is the top seller in this category.
Overnight oats and parfaits are the lighter, lower-calorie picks if you want something under $7.00. Prices may vary slightly by outlet based on ingredient availability.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| Ham & Swiss Croissant | Flaky croissant with warmed ham and swiss | $8.25 |
| Breakfast Sandwich Croissant | Scrambled eggs, ham, American cheese on croissant | $9.50 |
| French Toast Egg Sandwich | Eggs, bacon, cheese between French toast slices | $12.50 |
| Turkey Bacon Avocado Panini | Turkey, bacon, avocado, tomato, grilled panini | $12.50 |
| Yogurt Parfait | Layered yogurt with fresh fruit and granola | $6.50 |
| Vanilla Bean Overnight Oat | Oats soaked overnight with vanilla bean and chia | $6.85 |
| Strawberry Cheesecake Overnight Oat | Overnight oats, strawberries, graham cracker crumble | $6.95 |
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Acai Bowls & Mini Pancakes
Acai bowls are a signature category, priced between $14.50 and $16.00 depending on toppings. Mini pancakes offer a more budget-friendly sweet option starting at $8.50.
The Bowl Luxe is the most expensive single item on the entire menu. Prices may vary slightly by outlet, especially with fruit and topping substitutions.
| Menu Item | Description | Price (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| The Esther Bowl | Acai, granola, banana, strawberries, blueberries, honey | $14.50 |
| The Ruth Bowl | Blended acai topped with granola, fruit, and honey | $14.75 |
| The Bowl Luxe | Acai bowl with granola, fruit, and coconut flakes | $16.00 |
| 12 Mini Pancakes | Fluffy mini pancakes with toppings | $8.50 |
| Mini Pancake Breakfast Plate | Mini pancakes served with butter and syrup | $12.00 |
| 24 Mini Pancakes | Mini pancakes with banana, strawberries, Nutella | $15.99 |
But First Coffee Shop Menu US: Price Range Summary
| Category | Price Range (USD) |
|---|---|
| Hot Coffee & Espresso | $2.34 – $6.55 |
| Iced Lattes & Protein Lattes | $4.37 – $8.98 |
| Mocha, Hot Chocolate & Matcha | $5.15 – $8.75 |
| Teas & Juices | $4.11 – $6.76 |
| Toasts & Pastries | $4.50 – $15.00 |
| Fresh Kitchen & Breakfast | $6.50 – $12.50 |
| Acai Bowls & Mini Pancakes | $8.50 – $16.00 |
How to Order from But First Coffee Shop
You can order from But First Coffee Shop in person, through their online ordering system, or via a delivery app, depending on what’s most convenient. Here’s every option available in 2026:
- Online ordering directly through their Clover ordering page
- DoorDash or Uber Eats for delivery in the Orlando area
- Walk-in / Dine-in at the Orlando or Sky Lake locations
- Direct phone call or social media for questions and daily specials
Ordering ahead through the app is your best bet to skip the line during weekend rush hours.
Popular But First Coffee Shop Menu Items
Some items show up again and again in reviews, and they’re a reliable starting point if you’re ordering for the first time. These are the ones customers mention most.
| Item | Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| Frances Latte | $7.85 |
| Flan Latte | $8.95 |
| Breakfast Avocado Toast with Hot Honey Glaze | $14.00 |
| Ham & Swiss Croissant | $8.25 |
| The Esther Bowl | $14.50 |
Tip: Order a Frances Latte in a canned to-go cup if you want to enjoy the coffee later reviewers say it holds its flavor well over 24 hours.
Read: Stardust Video and Coffee Menu US
Read: Merit Coffee Menu US: Prices & Guide
Read: Idle Hour Coffee Menu US: Prices & Guide
Read: Ebru Coffee Roastery Menu US: Prices
Read: Brevity Coffee Menu US: Prices & Guide
Frequently Asked Questions
Conclusion
But First Coffee Shop menu US pricing stays reasonable for what you get in 2026, with coffee starting under $3 and food topping out around $16 for the biggest acai bowl. Whether you order online, through DoorDash, or walk in, it’s worth double-checking the current menu before you visit since prices can shift slightly by location.
